Vermont's Gov. Slams Anti-Gay Republicans
Friday, 18 May 2001

MONTPELIER -- Vermont's Gov. Howard Dean harshly criticized Republican leaders in the state House of Representatives for their dogged attempts to repeal the state's landmark civil unions law, the Rutland Herald reports.

Gov. Howard Dean
"It made me ashamed of the Legislature. It was one of the few times in this building I have been ashamed," said Dean, referring to a pair of amendments that appeared earlier this week on the House calendar asking the state to declare gay and lesbian relationships a "health hazard."

The House is expected to take up a bill next week that replaces civil unions for gay and lesbian couples with "reciprocal partnerships." The new bill provides same sex couples with many of the rights and benefits of civil union, but by allowing relatives to sign on as beneficiaries, it is seen by many Republicans as a "less offensive" alternative.

Anti-gay lawmakers in the House have also presented amendments to repeal the civil unions law without providing any replacement system. In both versions printed this week, a provision called on the state to prohibit same-sex marriage and declare same-sex sexual unions to be "health hazards, contrary to public policy."

Dean told reporters Wednesday that what he heard angered him. "Years from now when people read that legislation it's going to look like it would for us to go back to the 1830s in the south and read about slave owners," he said. "I think people's personal sexual lives ought to be off bounds for this House. I think it’s frankly embarrassing that something like that was printed in the calendar."

The Herald says GOP Rep. John Hall who sponsored one of the amendments, left the caucus momentarily speechless when he said he was considering removing the health hazard provision from his proposal. Having discussed it with other lawmakers he said he had new reservations about specifying health risks associated with certain activities.

"What about paraplegics?" Hall said, noting that "when they make love it's oral."