C/NET News.Com
http://news.com.com/2010-1071_3-1024777.html
 
Microsoft And The 'Savage Nation'
By Charles Cooper
July 11, 2003
MSNBC this week saved co-owner Microsoft from a huge embarrassment by firing Michael Savage after he launched into an antigay tirade on the air. Now the software maker is free to turn the page and return to business as usual.
But, while the Redmond, Wash.-based company's handlers may be breathing a sigh of relief, the resolution of the Savage affair raises as many questions as it supposedly resolves.
On the surface, this is a simple story of a bad personnel hire. The "Savage Nation" talk show host blew his stack last Saturday and referred to a caller as a "sodomite." He went on to say, "You should only get AIDS (acquired immune deficiency syndrome) and die, you pig. How's that?...You got nothing better than to put me down, you piece of garbage. You have got nothing to do today. Go eat a sausage and choke on it."
MSNBC later said Savage's comments were "extremely inappropriate" and that the decision was an easy one. If it was so easy, I wonder why the programming geniuses at MSNBC put him on the air in the first place? Savage had been variously quoted calling gays and lesbians "perverts" and Asians "little soy eaters," and saying immigrants are from "Turd World" nations on his nationally broadcast radio program.
But that's less interesting than why Microsoft, a company that carefully manages its public image, remained inexplicably passive throughout the escalating controversy over Savage's hiring last March. Because Savage's show was on MSNBC, Microsoft argued that this was an editorial issue--a question of church and state--and thus beyond its ken. (General Electric owns the other half of MSNBC, as it is the full owner of NBC.)
In a public statement a few months ago, Microsoft said it "strongly supports the editorial independence of MSNBC and respects Mr. Savage's right to express his views. However, we do not agree with Mr. Savage's statements regarding women and minorities, and his opinions do not reflect our corporate values. Microsoft is committed to fostering diversity and respectful public dialog."
That boilerplate mush remained the party line to the end.
"It's MSNBC's decision to make," a Microsoft representative told me shortly before the network dumped Savage. "It's not a matter of (whether) we support him or agree or not. We have a relationship with MSNBC where we do not provide any input into programming. There's a very clear demarcation."
But Microsoft is a media power. Doesn't it have any responsibility when it helps to support the employment of someone who regularly insults nonwhites and foreigners? I asked.
"We have stated that we don't agree with the views of Mr. Savage. However, we do respect his right to freedom of expression and the independence of MSNBC to put him on the air."
Up to a point, that made sense. Yet, it also avoided any deeper examination of where and how to draw the boundary between the software company and its own cable channel. There are red lines, and undoubtedly, figuring out the exact geography is a tricky exercise. But, along with ownership comes responsibility--even at its most benign. It just goes with the territory.
To its credit, Microsoft did keep its opinions to itself when Brock Meeks, a crack reporter who writes for the MSNBC Web site, regularly hung the company out to dry with his brilliantly acerbic coverage of the Microsoft antitrust trial.
Still, making fun of sundry Microsoft muckety-mucks getting defenestrated by antitrust lawyer David Boies is relatively tame stuff. What about the other extreme? I'd like to believe that Microsoft would have intervened if MSNBC had gone completely off its collective rocker and hired former Ku Klux Klan leader David Duke. Otherwise, you're left with the impression that as long as the money from the joint venture keeps rolling in, Steve Ballmer and company couldn't care less.
High-minded statements of virtue are fine, but when its cable channel moved beyond the pale, Microsoft looked the other way. Michael Savage is obviously no David Duke, but how could his employment have failed to set off alarms in Redmond?
San Francisco Chronicle
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2003/07/09/MN158024.DTL
 
Savage Says He's Sorry -- But Stays Fired
Talk show host insists epithets not aimed at people with AIDS
Dan Fost, Chronicle Staff Writer
July 9, 2003
Click to View
Michael Savage, the outrageous talk show host who was fired from MSNBC on Monday for telling a caller to "get AIDS and die," fought back Tuesday, saying he was reacting to a crank caller.

Savage, the most successful radio host ever to emerge from the Bay Area, said his controversial comments were aimed only at the caller, and that he thought he was off the air when he said them. He also blasted MSNBC for criticizing him.

"I'm sitting in front of the camera. I have no control over that," Savage said. "In radio, I have total control. . . . He got really vile with me . . . I meant to insult him personally, not all people with AIDS."

On his Web site, www.michaelsavage.com, Savage apologized to gays, and for causing anyone pain with his comments.

The apology is not enough to save his show. MSNBC spokesman Jeremy Gaines refused to comment on Savage's response and would only reiterate an earlier statement that Savage "made an extremely inappropriate remark. The decision to cancel the program was not a difficult one."

SAVAGE FEELS 'INJURED'

Savage said those remarks stung.

"They didn't have to make a comment which in any way injured me," Savage said. "They put the leper bells around me. I'm dead in the water on television. "

Savage, 61, has drawn fire since he first showed up on San Francisco's KSFO (560 AM) in 1994, when the station adopted a conservative talk radio format. The former Michael Weiner, an herbalist and nutritionist who had written 18 books, reinvented himself as a vitriolic talk show host, and became a phenomenon.

Last week, he jumped to rival KNEW (910 AM) in a lucrative deal. His show is heard nationally on 300 radio stations, reaching about 5 million people.

MSNBC, the cable network jointly owned by NBC (a unit of General Electric) and Microsoft, hired Savage in February to boost its sagging ratings.

MSNBC WAS 'WARNED'

"It's fair to say that we warned MSNBC that something like this would happen eventually," said Cathy Renna, news media director for the Gay and Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation, an advocacy group.

GLAAD, which had long objected to what it viewed as Savage's homophobic rants, had led an advertiser boycott of Savage's show, "The Savage Nation," that kept big consumer companies like Kraft, Procter and Gamble, and Dell Computer off his sponsor list.

Jeff Perlstein, executive director of Media Alliance in San Francisco, said the organization "was alarmed at his hiring in the first place, particularly because (MSNBC) was replacing Phil Donahue, who was someone fostering lots of civic participation in society, with Michael Savage, who is known for all sorts of hate speech."

Savage believes liberal groups are stifling his First Amendment rights. Perlstein said he supports Savage's rights, but not on public airwaves, and Renna said she objected to Savage wrapping his opinions in the mantle of NBC's journalistic credibility.

On his radio show Tuesday, Savage showed no sign of shelving his combative persona, assailing President Bush (for comments about slavery), Chicago Cubs manager Dusty Baker (for comments about race), fellow conservative host Bill O'Reilly (for criticizing Savage's televised remarks) and Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg (a "radical left-wing buck-toothed hag").

"I'm proud of my work on television," Savage told one caller. "I was the first one in MSNBC history to dig up the photos of the gassed Kurds. . . . I made America see what Saddam Hussein had really done."

At another point, he said: "I slept quite well. I slept like a baby. I snoozed like a lamb. Because I believe in freedom of speech. The American people understand what went on. I am the underdog. I am Daniel in the lions' den. I am a victim. They know very very well that the left are like jackals in this country. They do not believe in freedom of speech, they only believe in freedom of their speech."

Savage's firing was precipitated by an active prankster calling his show. Bob Foster, 39, a Sacramento computer technician, says he's been on CNN 25 times -- including three times on Larry King's show -- and once convinced a Fox News host that he was witnessing an earthquake, when he was really making the whole thing up. Foster usually gives a plug to his favorite radio show, "Don and Mike," which emanates from Washington, D.C.

Foster called Savage's show Saturday when Savage was doing what he described as a "schtick" about airline horror stories. Foster started a yarn about someone smoking in a plane's bathroom, and then, in a non sequitur, said,

" 'Don and Mike' should take over your show so you can go to a dentist appointment, because your teeth are really bad."

Most of that comment was bleeped off the airwaves, but what Savage said was not. Instead, his rant will likely live in infamy.

He asked Foster if he was a "sodomite," and when Foster replied yes, Savage said -- according to a transcript posted on GLAAD's Web site (www.glaad.org), along with the video: "Oh, you're one of the sodomites! You should only get AIDS and die, you pig! How's that? Why don't you see if you can sue me, you pig? You got nothing better than to put me down, you piece of garbage? You got nothing to do today? Go eat a sausage and choke on it. Get trichinosis. OK, got another nice caller here who's busy because he didn't have a nice night in the bathhouse and is angry at me today?"

Savage said he immediately asked if that got on the air, but didn't receive an answer.

He said his show had been gaining traction. According to MSNBC, it had a viewership of about 347,000 total viewers.

Although that is a small rating -- less than a single percentage point -- Savage said he had dinner with MSNBC President Erik Sorenson two weeks ago, and Sorenson told him, "We don't care about your ratings. We love your show."

Sorenson, through spokesman Gaines, declined to comment.

"They were too quick to jump the gun," Savage said. "It's been a struggle from day one. They don't want to switch to anything moderate or conservative. The bias is very liberal."

Foster, the prankster, said he's already getting a lot of "hate mail from the Savage nation."

"My intention was not for him to get fired. My intention was to drop the 'Don and Mike' name,' " Foster said.

In fact, Foster is a fan of Savage's show, and he picked him for one simple reason: "I look for a reaction."

E-mail Dan Fost at dfost@sfchronicle.com.

Fox News Channel
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,91255,00.html
 
MSNBC Makes 'Easy' Decision to Fire Michael Savage
Associated Press
July 8, 2003
 
NEW YORK  — MSNBC on Monday fired Michael Savage for anti-gay comments.
 
The popular radio talk show host who did a weekend TV show for the cable channel referred to an unidentified caller to his show Saturday as a "sodomite" and said he should "get AIDS and die."

"His comments were extremely inappropriate and the decision was an easy one," MSNBC spokesman Jeremy Gaines said.

There was no immediate comment from Savage, according to a spokesman at his office in California.

The brash, tough-talking Savage is one of radio's hottest jocks. His Paul Revere Society advocates closing borders, deporting illegal immigrants, mandating health tests for immigrants and eliminating entitlement programs.

The televised version of "The Savage Nation" began March 8 despite the protests of such advocacy groups as the Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation.

Aired at 5 p.m. EDT Saturday, Savage didn't translate into a television hit. He increased the ratings for the time slot marginally, according to MSNBC.

The incident that resulted in his firing began innocently enough. Savage was taking viewer phone calls about airline horror stories, and a male caller began talking about smoking in the bathroom.

"Half an hour into the flight, I need to suggest that Don and Mike take your ..." the caller said, before he was cut off and his words became unintelligible.

"So you're one of those sodomists. Are you a sodomite?" Savage asked.

The caller replied: "Yes, I am."

"Oh, you're one of the sodomites," Savage said. "You should only get AIDS and die, you pig. How's that? Why don't you see if you can sue me, you pig. You got nothing better than to put me down, you piece of garbage. You have got nothing to do today, go eat a sausage and choke on it."

He asked for another phone caller who "didn't have a nice night in the bathhouse who's angry at me today."

These bums "mean nothing to me," he said.

GLAAD spokeswoman Cathy Renna said of Savage's firing: "It's about time.

"This latest attack made the clearest case for why Savage has no place on any reputable news network. MSNBC witnessed firsthand exactly the kind of verbal assaults GLAAD's been warning them about for the past five months, and to their credit, they backed up their promises to hold Savage accountable."

 
Entertainment - Reuters TV
http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=597&ncid=762&e=8&u=/nm/20030707/tv_nm/television_msnbc_dc
 
MSNBC Fires Host Savage for Wishing AIDS on Caller
By Ben Berkowitz
July 7, 2003

LOS ANGELES (Reuters) - Cable news channel MSNBC on Monday fired Michael Savage after the controversial talk show host wished AIDS on a caller whom he dismissed as "one of the sodomites."

Savage had been under fire from gay rights groups since February when the network announced it had hired the conservative commentator to host a TV version of his popular talk radio show.

Saturday's episode of "The Savage Nation," his 15th since the program's debut in March, featured Savage discussing air travel with callers.

One caller began discussing his experiences, and after an unintelligible part of the call, Savage asked him "So are you one of those sodomists?"

When the caller said, "Yes I am," Savage, reclining in a chair with his arms folded and wearing dark sunglasses, responded, "Oh, you're one of the sodomites! You should only get AIDS and die, you pig!" in a clip of the show hosted on the Web site of the Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation.

An MSNBC representative was not immediately available to comment, but a source familiar with the matter confirmed that the show had been canceled.

GLAAD, which from the start campaigned against MSNBC's hiring of Savage, cheered the cancellation.

"Michael Savage's latest rant made the clearest possible case for why this kind of behavior has no place on any reputable news network," GLAAD spokeswoman Cathy Renna said in a statement.

In addition to his radio and TV show, Savage founded the Paul Revere Society, which advocates closing the U.S. borders, eliminating bilingual education and ending affirmative action programs.

A message left at a number listed for the Paul Revere Society in the northern California city of Mill Valley was not immediately returned.

Savage, who according to his biography on a network Web site holds a doctorate in epidemiology and nutrition science, hosted his unabashedly conservative show from the well-known liberal bastion of San Francisco.

A network source said the show had averaged 347,000 viewers through its first 14 airings, not including three weekends when the show was preempted by news coverage. It had aired Saturdays at 5 p.m. ET.

Savage was hired around the time the network canceled liberal talk-show host Phil Donahue, who in turn reportedly accused MSNBC of trying to "outfox Fox," a reference to Fox News Channel, often characterized as being conservative.

MSNBC is a partnership of the NBC unit of General Electric Co. and Microsoft Corp.

Close Window to Return to Say No 2 Hate Radio