Orlando Sentinel
Florida Governor Might Support Constitutional
Amendment if Courts Open Door to Unions in State
By Bob Mahlburg Tallahassee Bureau
November 10, 2004
TALLAHASSEE -- Republican Gov. Jeb Bush
weighed in on the explosive issue of same sex marriage Tuesday, saying he might
support a state constitutional amendment banning gay marriage if the courts open
the door to such unions in Florida.
It was his strongest statement yet on
the issue and came the same day that the Florida Baptist State Convention in
Jacksonville unanimously agreed to seek a constitutional amendment that defines
marriage as the union of a man and a woman.
Bush said he thinks the
state's Defense of Marriage Act prohibits gay marriages, but he might back
putting a constitutional question on the ballot if court rulings force the
issue.
"If there was a threat that gay marriage would be accepted in our
state, then I might be supportive of it," Bush said. "I'm not sure it's
necessary to do this in a pre-emptive fashion."
Bush said he thinks the
Legislature would enthusiastically back a constitutional move to ban same-sex
marriages if conditions change.
Gay groups and some liberal state
lawmakers pounced on the governor's comment, saying it could signal a political
move to push for a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage such as
those passed last week in 11 states.
"We're talking about civil marriage,
and the government has no place in that," said Brian Winfield, a spokesman for
Tampa-based Equality Florida, the state's largest gay and lesbian advocacy
group.
But some religious leaders hailed Bush's words, saying they
strongly back a constitutional amendment because it would support traditional
views of matrimony.
"For thousands of years, marriage has been between a
man and a woman," said the Rev. Jerry Walsh of Seminole Community Church in
Sanford. "It concerns me that the courts can redefine what American and human
culture have accepted as the norm."
Florida made history as the first
state in the nation to ban gay marriages in the 1970s amid a controversial
campaign by singer Anita Bryant. But it does not have a constitutional ban such
as those adopted in 11 states on Election Day. Legal challenges already have
been filed against such bans in several states.
Gov. Bush's comments
don't go nearly as far as his brother, President Bush, who has called for an
amendment to the U.S. Constitution banning same-sex
marriage.
Nevertheless, State Rep. Ron Greenstein, D-Coconut Creek,
called the governor's support for a constitutional amendment blatantly
political.
"The statutes are very clear that they ban gay marriage in
Florida," Greenstein said. "But I think the Republicans are really looking at
it. They want to drive a final stake in the hearts of
Democrats."
Greenstein said he had already heard rumors that Republican
state lawmakers would push to put a constitutional amendment banning gay
marriage on the ballot in 2006 to damage Democratic candidates and energize the
conservative Christian Republican base that has backed Gov. Bush and his
brother.
State Sen. Ron Klein, D-Delray Beach, the outgoing Senate
Democratic leader, was not so sure.
"Maybe he's signaling to the
Legislature, 'Don't do it right now,' " Klein said, noting a number of other
states have quickly passed such amendments.
Klein also questioned whether
Gov. Bush was trying to energize the Republican base.
"I don't think his
base needs energizing. His base knows where he stands on this stuff," Klein
said.
Equality Florida's Winfield said it's curious that Gov. Bush is
taking a more restrained position than the president.
"He [President
Bush] has led the charge on amending the U.S. Constitution to discriminate
against gay couples, so they seem to be taking opposite approaches," Winfield
said.
Some Florida religious leaders argue that putting a proposed ban on
same-sex marriage on the ballot simply lets voters decide.
"If there was
an amendment that went out for a vote, it would be up to the people of Florida.
That's the way our government works, " said the Rev. Rol Erickson, minister of
pastoral care, Northland, a Church Distributed, in Longwood. Erickson said he
would personally support such an amendment.
"Marriage is an institution
ordained by God that was designed for a man and a woman," he said.
But
Winfield argued that legal definitions of marriage have been evolving for
generations and will continue to do so.
"Marriage is not a stagnant
institution," he said. "Forty years ago, marriage was between a man and a woman
of the same race, and that was the law."
Mark Pinsky of the Sentinel
staff contributed to this report. Bob Mahlburg can be reached at bmahlburg@orlandosentinel.com
or 850-222-5564.
Close Window to Return
to DontAmend Tampa Bay Website